Wondering what "giving eye" means when it comes to border collies? In the world of dogs, there are many breeds selectively bred to perform several tasks. We have dogs bred for hunting, dogs bred for retrieving, dogs bred for guarding and even dogs bred for providing companionship and with a history of warming up the laps (lap dogs) and feet of aristocratic ladies. Border collies were selectively bred for herding, something these dogs do very well, hence why they're often referred to as "the workaholics of the canine world." In this breed, "giving eye" is something that is much appreciated by the shepherds, but can you guess what it exactly means for a border collie to give eye? So today's Trivia question is:
What does it mean when a border collie is "giving eye?"
A The border collie is staring at the sheep so to control motion
B The border collie is making eye contact with the shepherd as he eagerly waits further instructions
C The border collie is giving a mean, hard stare to the other dogs he's working with
D The border collie is keeping an eye on the flock making sure no wolves attack the sheep
The correct answer is: drum roll please....
The correct answer is: A, The border collie is staring at the sheep so to control motion
A Matter of Herding Style
Different herding dog breeds have different herding styles when it comes to moving sheep or cattle from one area to another.
These variances may have originated because of the different needs of the shepherd or perhaps the different set-ups found in a particular agricultural region.
We therefore have herding dogs who run and bark, herding dogs who nip at heels and even herding dogs who walk on the backs of sheep. When it comes to the herding style of border collies, their style is quite unique.
Border collies will stare intently at the sheep, "giving them eye." What does the border collie accomplish from giving eye to the sheep? A whole lot we should say, considering this breed's eagerness to get the the job done.
A Look Back in Time
A border collie's herding style is reminiscent of the past when a dog's ancestors were hunting. Back in the old days, in order to enjoy a meal, it was necessary to follow a precise sequence which is known as the predatory sequence. This sequence entailed giving eye, stalking, chasing, catching, killing, and of course, eating.
Catching, killing and eating is something that is out of question nowadays as herding dogs should never hurt their sheep. Fortunately, for the most part, it appears that a herding dog's predatory sequences has been “truncated," so to speak. In other words, it has been cut short.
So border collies will give eye, stalk, and chase and some may occasionally nip too particularly when dealing with stubborn sheep, but fortunately not very hard. However, it's generally quite frowned upon for a herding dog to show the grab/bite behavior typically seen in cattle heelers and some consider it a major fault.
"If you’ve ever seen a Border Collie herding sheep, you’ve watched a predator in action. "~ Jolanta Benal, dog trainer
An Eye for Herding
The border collie breed gains its name from the border between Scotland and England where this dog was considered a valuable asset, courtesy of his almost inborn aptitude to follow the shepherd's requests and his signature stare, the “eye,” with which this breed controls the flock. When border collies give eyes, they are orienting towards the sheep in a stalking position.
According to James Serpell, author of the book "The Domestic Dog: Its Evolution, Behaviour and Interactions with People" this giving eyebehavior is so strong that it seems to act as a reward on its own, and once it's present, the only way to stop it is to remove the dog from the stimulus contributing to the behavior.
"It's impossible to even to try to herd sheep with a pup until it shows eye. What a border collie handler does is to train the dog when and how to go in order to use the eye. But nobody can train a dog to show eye or to point."~Raymond Coppinger, Lorna Coppinger
Movement is a Trigger
What triggers a border collie to give eye? Experiments at Hampshire College showed that the eye giving behavior in border collies was in part stimulated by the anticipation of movement.
Indeed, when the border collies were introduced to a group of sedated chicken which were pretty much motionless (poor poultry!), they were not giving eye.
Instead, they were carrying out all sorts of displacement behaviors such as barking at the birds or play-bowing. However, giving eye behaviors promptly seemed to resume once the border collies detected movement (Coppinger et al, 1987)
How does the "giving eye" behavior get the sheep under control? It seems that sheep respond to it naturally because it mimics the intensity of posture seen in a wolf stalking its prey. It's sort of a way to "exert psychological pressure," so to say. John Holmes in the book "The Farmer's Dog," makes quite an interesting observation. He claims that the "eye " is more an attitude of approach than something connected with the dog's eye. Talk about the art of giving eye!
"A Border Collie moves livestock by controlled intimidation. He pushes them along with a threatening glare. This glare is called 'eye' and is probably related to the wolves' tactic of selecting a victim in the herd by catching its eye... before starting the attack run."~Donald McCaig
Did you know? When it comes to the amount of "eye" a dog has, dogs can be classified as having strong, medium or loose-eyes.
Border Collie At Work Using Eye
- The Domestic Dog: Its Evolution, Behaviour and Interactions with People, By James Serpell, Cambridge University Press; 1 edition (January 26, 1996)
- Dogs: A New Understanding of Canine Origin, Behavior and Evolution, By Raymond Coppinger, Lorna Coppinger, University Of Chicago Press; 1 edition (October 1, 2002)
- The Farmer's Dog, John Holmes, Popular Dogs Publishing; 10Rev Ed edition (1991)
The Border Collie uses a direct stare at sheep, known as "the eye", to intimidate while herding, by C. MacMillan - Original Work, CC BY 2.5
Border Collie herding by Jean-Michel Castelan/Design Madeleine - Collection privée CC BY-SA 3.0